Skip to Main Content

Spotlight on Broadway Talent: A Side-by-Side Comparison of Broadway Actors and their Real-life Counterparts

Beautiful Noise Neil Diamond Musical


Broadway has long been a platform for storytelling that transcends the realms of fiction. Its history is adorned with numerous productions that have taken inspiration from real-life figures, unfolding their stories in a colorful tapestry of song, dance, and drama. From the political intrigue of Hamilton to the heart-wrenching tale of Evita, Broadway's penchant for capturing the essence of real-life characters continues to captivate audiences. 

Portraying a real person on stage is an intricate art. It's a delicate balance between accurately representing the individual's character and bringing a unique spin that only the actor can provide. It's not about mimicry but rather capturing the essence of the person. This task becomes even more challenging when the main character is a well-known figure, as audiences come with preconceived ideas and expectations. 


A Beautiful Noise: Nick Fradiani as Neil Diamond 

A Beautiful Noise is the latest Broadway production inspired by a real-life musician. The show is a tribute to the life and music of Neil Diamond, one of the best-selling musicians of all time. The musical intertwines Diamond's iconic songs with his personal journey, giving audiences a glimpse into the man behind the music. 


Taking on the role of Neil Diamond is Nick Fradiani, a talented actor and musician who rose to fame as the winner of American Idol's 14th season. Fradiani's previous theatrical work includes roles in Broadway national tours like A Bronx Tale. His preparation for the role is a beautiful blend of personal history and professional dedication. Growing up with a father who was a lifelong musician and an ardent Neil Diamond fan, Fradiani was immersed in Diamond's music from a young age. As a child, he would often joke around and mimic the Neil Diamond voice while singing Christmas songs. For Fradiani, playing Neil Diamond is more than just another role - it's a passion project, a tribute to an artist who has profoundly influenced his life and career. "I just feel like it's something I'm supposed to do," said the actor in a recent interview. 


Hamilton: Trey Curtis as Alexander Hamilton


Hamilton is a revolutionary musical that has taken Broadway by storm. Lin-Manuel Miranda's genius creation presents the life and times of Alexander Hamilton, one of America's founding fathers, through a unique blend of hip-hop, R&B, and traditional show tunes. The show's innovative storytelling and diverse cast have redefined the way audiences engage with historical figures, making it a cultural phenomenon.


Though originally written and performed by Miranda himself, a number of actors have stepped into the role since Hamilton opened on Broadway almost ten years ago. Most recently, Trey Curtis has taken up the mantle, after Miguel Cervantes took his final bow on January 7th, 2024. Curtis is more than up to the task, after touring with various productions of the show both nationally and internationally since 2019,  and even performing on Broadway as a member of the ensemble last year, all the while understudying multiple roles, including Hamilton.


The show's portrayal of Hamilton, while grounded in historical facts, is not a literal representation. This Hamilton is a vibrant, flawed, and relatable character, a far cry from the stern figure often depicted in history books. While some details are embellished or altered for dramatic effect, the essence of Hamilton – his drive, intellect, and unwavering belief in his nation's potential – remains intact. 

MJ Michael Jackson Musical

MJ: Elijah Rhea Johnson as Michael Jackson 


MJ is a stunning musical that chronicles the life and career of the legendary Michael Jackson. Set against the backdrop of his preparation for the Dangerous World Tour, MJ explores the King of Pop's journey to pop stardom, highlighting his artistry, personal struggles, and enduring legacy.


Elijah Rhea Johnson, a rising Broadway star, has stepped into the monumental task of portraying Michael Jackson. His preparation for the role was exhaustive; one of the most challenging aspects was mastering Jackson's distinctive vocal style. "The hardest part is trying to maintain a vocal quality that is equally comfortable for me to do night after night, and equally sounds like you’re listening in on a conversation with MJ," Johnson explained. He watched numerous interviews and performances, striving to find a balance that was authentic to both Michael Jackson and himself. However, Johnson's connection to Jackson goes beyond his professional preparation. "My experience of music and dance started with Michael," Johnson recalled. "I was eight years old and my dad taught me how to moonwalk in our kitchen in Detroit. That was the first dance move I learned. It’s my touchstone for everything."


Johnson's performance is a testament to his hard work and talent. He captures Jackson's signature style and persona with remarkable accuracy, from his electrifying stage presence to his softer, more vulnerable moments off-stage.

And Juliet Broadway Musical

& Juliet: Betsy Wolfe as Anne Hathaway


& Juliet is a fresh take on the story behind one of the world's most famous plays - Romeo and Juliet. It imaginatively explores the relationship between William Shakespeare and his wife, Anne Hathaway, as they collaborate on the creation of this iconic tragedy. 


Taking on the role of Anne is Betsy Wolfe, a seasoned actress who has carved a distinct place for herself in the world of Broadway. Her outstanding performances in Waitress, Falsettos and The Mystery of Edwin Drood established her as a force to be reckoned with on Broadway.


In preparing for the role of Anne Hathaway, Betsy Wolfe faced a unique challenge: not much is known about the real Anne's personality. This lack of information, however, piqued Wolfe's interest and gave her the freedom to explore the character more deeply. She focused on understanding the dynamics of being a partner to a successful artist, like Shakespeare. Wolfe also aimed to make Anne likable, infusing her with warmth and relatability. "There are parts of her that I can't distinguish from myself anymore," Wolfe shared, highlighting the deep connection she has developed with Anne after playing her for over a year.


The importance of musicals like these lies in their ability to honor and retell the lives of renowned figures in a compelling, accessible manner. Through their expert blend of history and art, they not only entertain but also educate, inspire, and provoke thought, offering fresh perspectives on real-life individuals.


These productions represent the culmination of countless hours of hard work and dedication by incredibly talented actors. Their performances breathe life into these historical and iconic figures, revealing their human complexity and depth. As they step into the shoes of their characters, they bridge the gap between past and present, creating a personal connection that enriches our understanding and appreciation of these figures.


So, come and see these shows and immerse yourself in the rich tapestry of stories that these musicals present. Embrace the music, the emotion, and the history, and let these performances remind you of the power of art to illuminate the human experience in all its complexity and beauty.