Skip to Main Content

Discover Your New Favorite: Broadway Shows to Watch If You Loved the Classics

Hamilton Broadway Musical Group Sales Tickets

Broadway has been home to countless timeless classics that have enchanted audiences for decades. From the heart-wrenching drama of Les Miserables to the lively spectacle of The Phantom of the Opera, these shows have left an indelible mark on theatre-goers and have helped shape the Broadway landscape into what it is today. The magical melodies, compelling narratives, and larger-than-life performances have made these classics a staple of the Broadway scene, continually drawing in new audiences and maintaining their standing as must-see productions. 


However, the beauty of Broadway lies in its ability to constantly innovate and bring fresh, exciting productions to the stage. This is what keeps the theatre industry alive and ever-evolving. It's for this reason that we invite you to venture beyond the realm of the familiar and discover new shows that might be the next big hit on your personal favorites list. Building on the foundation laid by the classics, these contemporary shows infuse novel concepts, modern themes, and unique storytelling techniques, all while maintaining the enchantment that is quintessentially Broadway. 


Understanding the connection between classic and modern Broadway shows allows us to appreciate how the theatre industry has evolved while still honoring its roots. Modern shows may present fresh narratives and contemporary themes, but they carry forward the legacy of the classics in more ways than one might initially realize. They continue to explore the depth of the human condition, capture the essence of timeless stories, and draw upon the universal themes that resonate with audiences across generations.


One of the key elements that classics and modern shows share lies within the heart of any good theatre production: the story. Whether it's a tale of unrequited love, a journey of self-discovery, or a fight against societal norms, both classic and modern shows rely on strong narratives that captivate the audience, enabling them to see a reflection of their own experiences and emotions on stage. Characters, too, are a shared element. They may change in terms of their backgrounds, professions, or time periods, but their relatability, complexity, and growth remain central to the audience's connection with the play.


Lastly, the production itself, encompassing everything from set design to choreography, is a shared element that bridges the gap between classic and modern shows. The spectacle of Broadway, the ability to create a transformative experience that transports the audience to a different world, is a common thread that runs through all shows, regardless of when they were created. This blend of story, characters, and production is what makes Broadway shows, both classic and modern, a unique and unforgettable experience.


Here are some new shows to catch on Broadway if you enjoyed the classics!

Sweeney Todd Broadway Musical Show Group Discounts

Phantom of the Opera and Sweeney Todd (2023 revival)

The Phantom of the Opera, a cornerstone of the Broadway classics, has enchanted audiences since its premiere in 1988. Its iconic main character, historical drama genre, and eerie atmosphere have been integral to its enduring success. For lovers of this tale of obsession and unrequited love set against the backdrop of the Paris Opera House, we recommend a Broadway production that shares these evocative elements: Sweeney Todd.


The 2023 revival of Sweeney Todd echoes the dramatic intensity and brooding atmosphere of The Phantom. The titular character of Sweeney Todd, played by Aaron Tveit, is a complex, driven individual whose actions are fueled by a deeply personal motive, just like the Phantom. The historical drama genre is alive and well in Sweeney Todd, as it transports audiences to Victorian-era London, a setting as atmospheric and integral to the narrative as the opera house is to the Phantom.


Furthermore, fans of The Phantom of the Opera's eerie and gothic ambiance will find similar elements in Sweeney Todd. The score, set design, and lighting all contribute to an atmosphere that is simultaneously chilling and captivating. 


Annie and Aladdin


The beloved musical, Annie, has long been a Broadway favorite due to its uplifting story of a young girl who overcomes adversity, rising from her humble beginnings in an orphanage to find a loving family and a better life. With its catchy tunes, lovable characters, and heartwarming narrative, Annie has touched the hearts of many. If you're a fan of Annie's inspiring story, explore the newer Broadway production of Aladdin, which shares many of these compelling themes.


Aladdin, much like Annie, tells the tale of a main character who rises from a life of poverty to embark on an extraordinary adventure. Aladdin, a "diamond in the rough," mirrors Annie in his determination, resilience, and unwavering hope for a better future. Both characters remind audiences of the power of dreams and the potential for change, no matter where one starts in life. Both shows are testaments to the power of determination, courage, and the human spirit. 

And Juliet Broadway Musical Group Discounts

Grease and & Juliet 

Grease, a classic Broadway show that has made its mark with its high-energy performances, catchy tunes, and a nostalgic look back at high school life in the 1950s, is beloved for its coming of age narrative and distinct style. A tale of teenage dreams, love, and friendship, Grease has captured the hearts of audiences worldwide. If you're a fan of its vibrant energy and youthful narrative, you might find a new favorite in & Juliet.


This newer addition to the Broadway scene shares the essence of Grease's coming-of-age tale. It offers a fresh twist on the classic story of Shakespeare's Juliet, imagining her life had she not died at the end of the original play. The narrative follows Juliet's journey as she grapples with love, identity, and growing up, much like the characters in Grease.


Colorful style, another key element of Grease, is also a central feature of & Juliet. Both shows are replete with vibrant costumes, dynamic set designs, and energetic choreography that give them a distinctly lively feel. Moreover, & Juliet’s pop-infused score, featuring hits from acclaimed songwriter Max Martin, injects a youthful energy that echoes the rock 'n' roll spirit of Grease.


West Side Story and Hamilton


West Side Story, a classic of Broadway, has captivated audiences for generations with its unforgettable musical score and significant cultural impact. The tale, a modern retelling of Romeo and Juliet set amidst rival gangs in New York City, has resonated with audiences for its poignant exploration of love, prejudice, and the human condition. For those who appreciate the profound themes and musical magic of West Side Story, a modern show that carries forward this legacy is Hamilton.


Much like West Side Story, Hamilton is renowned for its unforgettable musical score. The music of Hamilton, composed by Lin-Manuel Miranda, has been hailed as a revolutionary blend of hip-hop, R&B, pop, and traditional show tunes. This diverse soundscape mirrors the eclectic mix of classical and contemporary music that Leonard Bernstein infused into West Side Story's score.


Moreover, both shows are deeply significant in their cultural impact. West Side Story broke new ground with its exploration of racial tension and societal conflict, themes that were relatively new to the Broadway stage at the time. Similarly, Hamilton has made waves with its unapologetic dive into American history, its diverse casting, and its modern musical style, presenting a fresh perspective and pushing the boundaries of what is traditionally expected of a Broadway show.

Hadestown Broadway Musical Group Discounts

Into the Woods and Hadestown 


Into the Woods, a classic Broadway show, weaves together various fairy tales into a narrative that explores the complex nature of wishes, dreams, and the choices we make. With its tragic romantic plots and inspiration drawn from pre-existing tales, Into the Woods has been a favorite among audiences for its unique storytelling and emotional depth. If you admire the intricate plot and fairytale inspiration of Into the Woods, we suggest checking out the modern production of Hadestown.


Hadestown, much like Into the Woods, features tragic romantic plots that tug at the heartstrings. It presents the ancient Greek myths of Orpheus and Eurydice, and Hades and Persephone, in a narrative that explores love, sacrifice, and the relentless pursuit of dreams - themes that echo the emotional depth and complexity of Into the Woods.


Moreover, Hadestown draws heavily from pre-existing myths for inspiration, much like Into the Woods does with fairy tales. This shared approach to storytelling allows both shows to delve into familiar narratives and characters, while also offering fresh interpretations and perspectives that make the stories their own. Both shows also share a unique blend of the fantastical and the real, creating worlds that are both magical and deeply human. 


As we conclude our exploration of Broadway classics and their modern counterparts, we hope we've ignited a spark of curiosity in you to venture into the contemporary landscape of Broadway. These shows are just a few examples of how modern productions carry forward the legacy of the classics, while also bringing fresh perspectives and innovative storytelling techniques to the stage.


Step beyond the realm of the familiar and immerse yourself in these newer productions. Each one has its unique charm, narrative strength, and creative flair that could potentially capture your heart just as the classics did.


Broadway's beauty lies in its ever-evolving nature, its ability to innovate, and its enduring commitment to storytelling that resonates with audiences across generations. Journey into the world of modern Broadway shows, and who knows? Your new favorite may just be a show away.