The Broadway Theatre District isn’t just where dreams take center stage—it’s also a hotspot for unforgettable culinary adventures. Between the dazzling lights and show-stopping tunes, you’ll find a treasure trove of dining spots to suit every craving and budget. It’s like New York’s unofficial boot camp for the indecisive, where the hardest choice might just be between a quick bite or a full-on feast—well, aside from picking which show to see. So gather your theatre-loving crew and dive into a dining experience that could rival the main event.
Planning ahead is essential when aiming to enjoy both a meal and a Broadway show. Making reservations in advance can save your party from long waits, whether you're a small group or a large gathering, as popular spots fill up quickly. When dining before a show, it's helpful to let your server know of your performance time to ensure you're on schedule. Many restaurants even offer pre-theatre menus, making it easy to enjoy a great meal without missing curtain time. If you’re looking for a bite post-show, check kitchen closing times, as some places switch to bar service later in the evening. With thoughtful pre-planning, you can savor a dining experience that seamlessly complements your Broadway adventure.
Here are just a few of our favorite Theatre District restaurants for you to enjoy.
Sardi's is a legendary restaurant that boasts a deep-rooted connection to Broadway since opening its doors in 1927. A favorite haunt for theatregoers, performers, and industry insiders alike, Sardi's exudes a timeless charm that has captivated its diverse clientele over the decades. One of its most iconic features is the collection of celebrity caricatures gracing the walls, showcasing the many famous faces who have visited over the years. New caricatures are added to the walls every season (recently, George Clooney, Nicole Scherzinger, and Cole Escola), joining legends like Julie Andrews, Stephen Sondheim, Bernadette Peters, and Chita Rivera. And keep your eyes peeled for the world’s most famous frog—Kermit! You’ll find him smiling down from a column at the top of the stairs.
Junior's has two locations in the Theatre District, strategically situated near Times Square and easily accessible for anyone visiting the Broadway area. Known for its vibrant atmosphere, Junior's provides an extensive menu featuring a diverse selection of dishes that cater to various tastes and preferences. Be sure to save room for dessert—after all, they do claim to have “the world’s most fabulous cheesecake,” and honestly, you’d be a fool not to test their claim.
John's Pizzeria is a favorite among theatregoers for its authentic coal-fired pizzas and welcoming vibe. The restaurant's rustic, spacious setting can comfortably accommodate larger groups, making it an excellent choice for pre-show dining for not just family and friends, but also student groups and bus tours. Known for their signature pies (that’s how we say “pizza” in New York), salads, and Italian specialties, John's Pizzeria caters to a wide array of tastes while maintaining that beloved New York pizza authenticity, adding a delicious start to your Broadway adventure.
Lillie's Victorian Establishment is a captivating venue that transports you back to the opulent days of the Victorian era. Located in the heart of the Theatre District, this enchanting restaurant and bar incorporate exquisite 19th-century decor, including intricately carved woodwork, stained glass, and period antiques. Perfectly blending elegance and charm, Lillie's offers a unique dining experience with a menu that features both classic comfort foods and inventive cocktails. The ambiance alone makes it a memorable spot for both pre-show dinners and post-theatre drinks, offering guests an experience that complements the historic essence of Broadway itself.
Carmine’s is a warm, welcoming eatery tucked into the heart of the bustling Broadway district, known for its family-style Italian dining—perfect for gathering with friends or family before a show. Famous for its generous, shareable portions, Carmine’s makes sure no one leaves hungry (or without a to-go box the size of a suitcase). From classic pastas to fresh seafood, the menu offers something for everyone. A visit to Carmine’s sets the stage for a delicious meal before the curtain rises.
Joe Allen is a laid-back spot where theater buffs can enjoy a tasty meal with a side of Broadway trivia. What really sets this place apart is the infamous Wall of Broadway Flops—it’s like a hall of fame, but for shows that might have taken a bit of a nosedive, like "Moose Murders" or "Dance of the Vampires." This quirky collection is sure to spark some entertaining dinner conversation. Dining at Joe Allen is all about great food and a good laugh, making it the perfect kickoff for your theater night. Remember, flop or not, you're always a star at Joe's!
Glass House Tavern, located just steps away from the heart of Broadway, offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere perfect for winding down after a show. Known for its delectable American cuisine and elegant setting, this popular dining spot frequently attracts performers from nearby theatres, making it a popular choice for post-show dining. With a bit of luck, you might even catch a glimpse of Broadway stars enjoying a meal after the curtain falls, adding an extra layer of excitement to your evening.
Sugar Factory in Times Square is the go-to spot for treating yourself to a post-show dessert after a Broadway performance. Known for its fun atmosphere and a menu that caters to every dessert lover's dream, it offers everything from over-the-top milkshakes to shareable sundaes. With an entire dessert menu worth drooling over, this lively place makes a sweet encore to your Broadway night—where in true diva fashion, the dessert is guaranteed to steal the show!
Walking around Times Square before hitting a Broadway show is a great way to get into the spirit of the night. This buzzing area, with its bright billboards and electric atmosphere, sets the perfect mood for an exciting evening. Plus, it helps build up an appetite for some of the amazing food options nearby! From grabbing a quick bite to planning a sit-down meal, there’s something to satisfy everyone's cravings. If you're looking to make your Broadway experience even better, check out some cool pre- and post-show suggestions on Broadway Inbound. They’ve got all the tips you need to plan a spectacular night. Embrace the vibrant energy of Times Square and make your time in the city as fun and memorable as the show itself!